Talk to a Lawyer Day or Night 24/7
Been Charged? Speak to a Criminal Defense Lawyer in Regina Now

The Intersection of Criminal and Civil Law: Understanding the Impact of a Guilty Plea

Being accused of a serious crime such as sexual assault, aggravated assault, or even a minor assault can result in the complainant suing you for damages in civil court. The damages awarded can be substantial, especially in sexual assault cases where victims can suffer serious psychological, emotional, and physical harm. 

Understanding the Impact of a Guilty Plea

If you plead guilty to a criminal charge, you’re admitting that you committed the crime. This admission can be used against you in civil proceedings, where the complainant may sue you for damages. By pleading guilty to the crime in criminal court, you’re essentially admitting liability in the civil lawsuit. This means that the complainant can use your guilty plea to prove that you’re responsible for the harm they suffered.

The Impact on Sexual Assault Cases

In sexual assault cases, damages awarded can be particularly significant given the nature of the harm suffered by the victim. Victims of sexual assault can experience long-lasting psychological and emotional trauma, as well as physical injuries. If you plead guilty to a sexual assault charge in criminal court, your admission of guilt can be used against you in a civil lawsuit.

By pleading guilty to the crime in criminal court, you’re admitting that you committed the sexual assault. The complainant can use this admission to prove that you’re liable for the harm they suffered. While there are some exceptions to this rule, in most cases, liability will be established if you plead guilty to a sexual assault charge.

The Impact on Aggravated Assault Cases

In aggravated assault cases, damages awarded can also be significant given the severity of the injuries suffered by the victim. Aggravated assault involves intentionally causing serious harm to another person, which can result in physical injuries such as broken bones, internal injuries, and brain damage.

If you plead guilty to an aggravated assault charge in criminal court, your admission of guilt can be used against you in a civil lawsuit. The complainant can use your guilty plea to establish liability and prove that you’re responsible for the harm they suffered. Again, while there are some exceptions to this rule, in most cases, liability will be established if you plead guilty to an aggravated assault charge.

The Impact on Minor Assault Cases

Even in cases involving minor assault, damages awarded can still be significant. Minor assault involves intentionally causing harm to another person, but the injuries suffered are less severe than in cases of aggravated assault.

If you plead guilty to a minor assault charge in criminal court, your admission of guilt can still be used against you in a civil lawsuit. The complainant can use your guilty plea to prove that you’re responsible for the harm they suffered, and liability will be established if you plead guilty to the charge.

Exceptions to the Rule

While the general rule is that a guilty plea in criminal court can be used against you in a civil lawsuit, there are some exceptions. For example, if you plead guilty to a criminal charge but the evidence used to establish your guilt in criminal court is different from the evidence required to prove liability in the civil lawsuit, then your guilty plea may not be admissible as evidence in the civil case.

Similarly, if the complainant in the civil lawsuit is seeking damages for harm that occurred before the criminal charge was laid, then your guilty plea may not be admissible as evidence in the civil case.

Conclusion

If you’re facing criminal charges for sexual assault, aggravated assault, or even a minor assault, it’s important to understand the potential impact of a guilty plea on a civil lawsuit. By pleading guilty in criminal court, you could be providing the complainant with a powerful tool to use against you in a civil lawsuit. While it’s true that pleading guilty can result in a reduced sentence or other benefits, such as a plea deal, the potential consequences of a guilty plea in a civil lawsuit should not be overlooked. 

It’s important to remember that a civil lawsuit can result in significant damages awards, and the standard of proof required is lower than in criminal cases. Therefore, before making any decisions, it’s essential to discuss the potential impact of a guilty plea on any civil lawsuit with a lawyer. A lawyer can help you understand your legal options and make an informed decision that takes into account all potential consequences. Additionally, if you do decide to plead guilty, your lawyer can help negotiate a plea deal that limits the impact on any civil lawsuit.

Scroll to Top